Context Check: What the Hell is Going on With WordPress and WPEngine?

What is happening?

What Automattic Says

It has to be said and repeated: WP Engine is not WordPress. My own mother was confused and thought WP Engine was an official thing. Their branding, marketing, advertising, and entire promise to cus…

ReadArchived

Pending their legal claims and litigation against WordPress.org, WP Engine no longer has free access to WordPress.org’s resources.

ReadArchived

What WPEngine Says

PDF of the Cease and Desist Letter

WP Engine celebrates its longstanding commitment to the WordPress community, highlighting core contributions, community support, and ongoing innovation.

ReadArchived

Journalistic Rundowns

Matt Mullenweg unleashed a no-holds-barred tirade at WP Engine, which has been commercializing WordPress since 2010.

ReadArchived

The brouhaha in the WordPress community looks likely to escalate into a legal battle around trademarks.

ReadArchived

This story has been updated throughout with more details as the story has developed. We will continue to do so as the case and dispute are ongoing. The

ReadArchived

The employees accepted a severance package offered to those who disagreed with Matt Mullenweg's direction of WordPress and his fight with WP Engine.

ReadArchived

The WordPress situation devolves further, which raises an obvious question: What does this mean for every other open-source project?

ReadArchived

Hi everyone! Mathew Ingram here. This is The Torment Nexus (you can find out more about me and this newsletter — and why I chose to call it that — in my inaugural post.) Since this is only the fifth edition of the newsletter, I am still working out some bugs, so please bear with me. Thanks for reading – and if you decide to subscribe, or upgrade to paid, thank you for that as well! Your contributions allow me to continue doing this. None of these newsletters are behind a paywall at this point (I

ReadArchived

WordPress.org users are forced to confirm they are not "affiliated with WP Engine in any way, financially or otherwise" before registering a new account or logging in.

wordpress, NewsReadArchived

WordPress cofounder Matt Mullenweg has ignited a battle with third-party hosting service WP Engine. Here’s the latest on the drama.

ReadArchived

Matt Mullenweg, who founded WordPress more than two decades ago, finds himself in a legal battle against Silver Lake over the firm's ownership of WP Engine.

cnbc, Articles, Technology, Business, Social media, Breaking News: Technology, US: News, source:tagname:CNBC US Source, business newsReadArchived

Trademark royalties is one way to force support of open source, we guess

ReadArchived

The dispute between WordPress founder Matt Mullenweg and hosting provider WP Engine continues, with Mullenweg announcing that WordPress is “forking” a

ReadArchived

WordPress cofounder Matt Mullenweg is facing backlash after calling a rival hosting platform WP Engine a “cancer” to the WordPress community.

ReadArchived

This story has been updated throughout with more details as the story has developed. We will continue to do so as the case and dispute are ongoing. The

ReadArchived

The Problem and Potential Solutions

Matt attacked WP Engine, then the community fired back. Here are my thoughts on this dumpster fire and why we might be entering a very dangerous era for WordPress.

ReadArchived

I'm still catching up, but here's the next post in the Matt vs Everyone fiasco.

ReadArchived

How open source projects can balance Makers and Takers: lessons from Drupal's contribution credit system and recommendations for WordPress and other open source communities.

ReadArchived

I believe Matt Mullenweg's abuses of his unilateral, unchecked powers prove that it is in the best interest of the entire WordPress community that he be removed from power immediately.

ReadArchived

Matt –I had the pleasure of attending WCUS in Portland and was present for your presentation. In the broadest sense you believe that WP Engine is not contributing enough back to WordPress. I don’t believe the way it has been handled has been helpful to the community, in fact, I believe it has been harmful. I hope that trust can be regained and the Community can heal.

ReadArchived

Congratulations on your decision to fork WordPress! You’ve taken on a mammoth task, I’m impressed with your willingness step up to the challenge of a lifetime. I’m here to give so…

ReadArchived

The WordPress Foundation

The feud between Automattic and WP Engine has continued, with WordPress.org blocking access by WP Engine’s servers. In WP Engine Must Win, I wrote about my thoughts on the legal argument on this battle, and why it is important that WP Engine win the trademark case in order to protect the ecosystem. I also touched on the moral argument: The case […]

ReadArchived

24Sep2024

Chele Chiavacci Farley, Mark Ghosh, Matt Mullenweg, WordPress Foundation, AnalysisReadArchived

During an interview with The Verge, WordPress cofounder Matt Mullenweg said WordPress.org “belongs to me” and addressed the dispute with WP Engine.

ReadArchived

The Custom Fields Plugin

On behalf of the WordPress security team, I am announcing that we are invoking point 18 of the plugin directory guidelines and are forking Advanced Custom Fields (ACF) into a new plugin, Secure Cus…

ReadArchived

We were saddened and appalled by Matt Mullenweg’s actions this morning appropriating the Advanced Custom Fields plugin that our ACF team has been actively

ReadArchived

Advanced Custom Fields (ACF) is no longer on WordPress.org, sites running ACF. here is what you need to know and what actions to take.

ReadArchived

WordPress.org took control of WP Engine’s Advanced Custom Fields plugin, forking and renaming it “Secure Custom Fields.”

ReadArchived

On Contributions

Commit to the future of WordPress and the open web.

ReadArchived

As we learn more about the Matt vs WP Engine fight, it's time to clear up some major misconceptions.

ReadArchived

The Community Shifts

At the heart of our community is our shared pledge to create a space that is harassment-free, welcoming, and inclusive for all. Our Community Code of Conduct already outlines a clear set of expecta…

ReadArchived

At the beginning of September, I left my role as Head of Programs & Contributor Experience at Automattic and stepped away from the WordPress project. It has been An Adjustment, leaving such an invigorating role that, for a long time, I truly loved. In truth, I’m still processing my choice to leave a company and community I had been embedded in for six years.

ReadArchived
Welcome to the new Mods. Let's talk about how we move forward
byu/AspirePress inWordpress

While any plugin can have an unlimited number of committers and support reps, there is only one official owner of a plugin at any time. This…

ReadArchived

The Trademark Battle

Automattic founder Matt Mullenweg called WP Engine “a cancer to WordPress.”…

ReadArchived

On stage at WordCamp US last week, Matt Mullenweg gave a keynote presentation which made a wide range of points about contribution, the ethics of open source, and the commitments various companies make to contributing. In particular, he called out WP Engine in what was a fairly clear direction to the community to stop using […]

ReadArchived

Introduction On 3 October 2024, an Associate General Counsel at Automattic published a useful post on “WordPress Trademarks: A Legal Perspective”. The post is useful for a few reasons, including because it acknowledges, I believe for the first time during the current controversy, the role of nominative fair use. And so, in that sense, it contributes to the community’s understanding of Automattic’s take on the trademark issues. I have been saying for a while now that nominative fair use would likely be a central issue in any trademark litigation between Automattic and WP Engine. WP Engine’s court filing confirms that. Why I have written this post I have written this post because Automattic’s positions on: trademark infringement in its cease and desist letter to WP Engine; and nominative fair use in the post referred to above, are potentially significant for large numbers of other WordPress hosting providers (excluding WordPress.com). As a long-time user of WordPress, it concerns me that such an important topic is not being more openly discussed by other lawyers, particularly US trademark …

ReadArchived

Yeah ... the inside track of WordPress is a mess right now. I'm sure we all have opinions, so I figured I should log mine in as well.

ReadArchived

The WordPress Foundation owns and oversees the trademarks for the names and logos of WordPress as well as a few other WordPress-related brands. Trademarks are a signifier of a product’s identity an…

ReadArchived

One of the many lies in Silver Lake and WP Engine’s C&D was their claim that Automattic demanded money from them moments before our CEO Matt Mullenweg gave his keynote at WordCamp US. Tha…

ReadArchived

Even the best-known brands can find themselves in a legal tangle when it comes to trademark issues. And the current WordPress trademark spat reminds us that small businesses can get caught in the crossfire of these battles.

ReadArchived

Matt Mullenweg, the WordPress co-founder and Automattic CEO, has been embroiled in a very public and legal fight with WP Engine these last few weeks over

ReadArchived

Automattic

Last night, WP Engine filed a baseless lawsuit against Automattic, Matt Mullenweg, and WordPress.org. Their complaint is flawed, start to finish. We vehemently deny WP Engine’s allegations—which ar…

ReadArchived

Winston Churchill said, “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” Since I last blogged here, WP Engine filed a meritless lawsuit and Automattic responded, and there’s been a hurrica…,Winston Churchill said, “Never let a good crisis go to waste.” Since I last blogged here, WP Engine filed a meritless lawsuit and Automattic responded, and there’s been a hurrican…

ReadArchived

Last Friday we said goodbye to 159 colleagues as part of our alignment offer. It was a tough day, there are a lot of close relationships within Automattic, and goodbyes are always hard. On Monday,…,Last Friday we said goodbye to 159 colleagues as part of our alignment offer. It was a tough day, there are a lot of close relationships within Automattic, and goodbyes are always hard. On Monday, …

ReadArchived

Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg made another buyout offer this week, and threatened employees who speak to the press with termination.

wordpress, News, automatticReadArchived

Given the egregious legal attacks by WP Engine against WordPress co-founder Matt Mullenweg, a number of their customers have been looking for alternative hosting, and in return a number of hosts ha…

ReadArchived

Days after 159 people accepted Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg’s offer of a six-month severance package to employees who wanted to leave, the company

ReadArchived

On Blocking WPEngine

That escalated quickly

ReadArchived

This is an appeal to temporarily reconsider your recent decision to ban WP Engine from WordPress.org.

ReadArchived

%

ReadArchived

Why is this Happening?

The censored Reddit post on why Matt Mullenweg is really going after WP Engine.

ReadArchived

Much has been made about the verbal and legal spat between Automattic/Matt Mullenweg and WP Engine. There are plenty of arguments to be made for each side. However, I’d like to examine what I see as a broader issue. And it has nothing to do with Mullenweg’s role as project…

business, WordPress Community, AutomatticReadArchived

(This post should be read while listening to Wish by Joshua Redman. The writing is synchronized to the music reading speed.) Contributor day just wrapped up for Portland for WordCamp US. If you ev…,(This post should be read while listening to Wish by Joshua Redman. The writing is synchronized to the music reading speed.) Contributor day just wrapped up for Portland for WordCamp US. If you eve…

ReadArchived

Automattic, creator of Wordpress, is being sued by one of the largest WordPress hosting providers. The conflict fits into a trend of billion-dollar companies struggling to effectively monetize open source, and are changing tactics to limit their competition and increase their revenue.

ReadArchived

Matt Mullenweg

I knew going to war with Silver Lake, a $102B private equity firm, they would pull out every dirty trick to try to smear my name, do oppo research, imply I’m a mafia boss trying to extort th…,I knew going to war with Silver Lake, a $102B private equity firm, they would pull out every dirty trick to try to smear my name, do oppo research, imply I’m a mafia boss trying to extort the…

ReadArchived

Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg has rescinded an 8% licensing deal offered to WP Engine in September, suggesting that escalating tensions between the two companies could lead to a corporate acquisition by Automattic. In an interview with The Repository, Mullenweg said Automattic now wanted more than 8% of WP Engine’s annual revenue, or an equivalent of […]

ReadArchived

TL;DR: Matt Mullenweg, the CEO of Automattic, co-founder of WordPress, and single point of failure for WordPress.org is trying to bully me with legal threats over my commentary regarding his recent…

ReadArchived

If I close my eyes I can still smell the pages of well-worn books and feel their dusty spines, walking down the quiet aisles of the public library in the small town where I grew up. It wasn’t one o…

ReadArchived

The Community Reacts

Before diving into the details of this announcement, I want to address something important. I am, like all of you, a human being. Given the current tensions in the WordPress ecosystem, my decision to move from WP Engine to Automattic might evoke strong feelings. Whether you agree or disagree with this decision, please recognize me as a human. Please treat me with respect, even if you strongly oppose my choices. The WordPress community is one I care deeply about, and we all benefit from respectful dialogue, no matter our differences.

ReadArchived

The right to fork the software is at the heart of open source. WordPress itself started as a fork of the b2/cafelog project. WordPress was one of several forks from b2, which included b2++ (which e…

ReadArchived

If the revolution had a lobby, you’d be standing in it.

ReadArchived

As neither of the current Accessibility team representatives are able to log-in to WordPress.org, team meetings are suspended until further notice. Bug scrubs will continue to run as normal.

ReadArchived

Why do we exist? AspirePress Exists to be a community of individuals focused on helping WordPress become the platform we all aspire for it to be. Who are we? We are open-source maintainers, business owners and dedicated community volunteers. What do we do? We develop packages, plugins and tools for WordPress. Our source code is

ReadArchived

We restyle OpenPress using shadcn UI components, using OpenAgents to convert them from React to Laravel Blade.

ReadArchived

Relevant Previous Events

Matt Mullenweg, CEO of Tumblr owner Automattic, is supposed to be on sabbatical. Instead, he’s arguing with Tumblr users over an individual content

ReadArchived

Internal documents obtained by 404 Media show that Tumblr staff compiled users' data as part of a deal with Midjourney and OpenAI.

tumblr, wordpress, OpenAI, midjourney, automatticReadArchived

"No corporate arm of the law. Ghost would be free as in Mozilla, not as in Automattic ... Every decision made would be about improving the software, not the bottom line."